Thursday, August 11, 2005

A considered response to the jibes of Boofykatz

Before I address the recent comments of the learned Boof, I'd just like to say that I destroyed a man today at court.

And it was such a destruction and done with such vicious brutality that I never set foot in the court. His lawyer, a gentleman of some evil repute amongst my colleagues here, greeted me genially. I returned his politeness with instant hostility and a demand for a cigarette. I thrust a document into his shaking hand and demanded that his client sign it. It contained six admissions.

Moments later there came word that his client was withdrawing the application and with that I bid him good day and left.

This lawyer is no longer as famed as he was this morning.

Now, to Boof. He asks for my view, from a jurisprudential POV, on Galen Strawson's argument for determinism in retributive justice. Galen reckons he can prove that there is no such thing as free will. He reckons he can prove that beyond doubt.

He starts out by positing that a man can do what he wants. (Free will there, maybe?) But he cannot decide what he wants.

He discusses this and gives an example of a man deciding that he wants to do something. This is a want to want to do something. We are getting very close to the famous "but for test" used in law. It can get ridiculous if iterated too many times. Galen reckons that this second want is just there. It is a given, a default state. And because you cannot be the cause of yourself, you cannot be responsible for the desire to do something. I am pretty happy with that. I mean I'm not gonna tangle with Nietzsche. That guy was a fucker.

Now to determinism. The idea that shit has happened, shit is happening, and shit will happen, regardless of anything you decide to do about it. Because your decision to do something about the shit is already included in the shit about to happen. Shit is unstoppable.

So it's luck then. We're born into a state that we cannot control. A bloke can't be blamed or praised for being the way he is. So a person shouldn't heap praise on a particularly beautiful Siamese cat, for example, just for being a fucking cat. The cat can't help it. It may desire nothing more than to be a really pretty chichlid, but cannot. Due to it's irrevocable catness.

So I suppose that we should only have one punishment for any crime then. If you can't help it. If whatever your transgression was, it obviously wasn't your fault, cause you can't be the cause of yourself. I wonder what that penalty should be?

Let us try a thought experiment... "Good morning your Honour. Tendollarman for the defence. In view of Strawson's determinist theories, which are now enthusiastically and universally accepted, there isn't really any need for a plea, we all know that he did it, but that ultimately, he couldn't help it. Nietzsche made him do it apparently. It's just a matter of fixing the penalty."

"Yes, Tendollarman, I agree entirely. Death. Thankyou gentlemen, that that fucker away."

I mean, can there be any other penalty? Can there be? Really?

It's balls. There are so many layers involved in the commission of a crime that this sort of thinking is only useful in making policy. And I fucking hate policy. If shit is unstoppable then why have a police force? No. Shit is definately stoppable. You just have to fight it and fight it forever, push it back slowly. Uphill.

No, Galen is obviously clever, but his arguments are leaden (har har - couldn't resist that little joke for all you geologists out there). But I take the point that although we are free to choose, we can't elect not to choose. But most people don't understand the meaning of those little words the way blokes like Strawson et al do. But if you listen to these bastards they'll tell you there's no such thing as love and happiness and so on. Fuck that. I unilaterally hereby declare that notwithstanding the metaphysical impossibility of it, I will have free will and love and happiness, and you miserable bastard navel gazing theoreticians can be as philosophical about it as you like about it. In fact the reason you bastards don't have any free will is because I took it. All of it. All your free will are belong to us. Someone set us up the love.

Thank me for the obscura.

PS Does anyone else think it is a bit ironic that this man is now looking for a job because he sought to practise his craft without having first obtained a certificate, and yet I don't have a practising certificate?

3 Comments:

Blogger Zendecks said...

woohoo!

2:03 pm  
Blogger MikeS said...

Good try Lawyerboy, but wrong. The retributive sentence should be zero, zilch, de nada. That is not to say no action should be taken. Any action should be in the considered best interests of society at large; and before you tell me that the sentence will be whatever shit is going to happen - yes, it will - the fact is that human activity is incommensurable with metaphysics. As Gilbert Ryle put it, there is a category error.

8:31 pm  
Blogger MikeS said...

And incidentally
'So a person shouldn't heap praise on a particularly beautiful Siamese cat, for example, just for being a fucking cat. The cat can't help it. It may desire nothing more than to be a really pretty chichlid, but cannot. Due to it's irrevocable catness.'

Only a fnool would heap praise on a Siamese cat. One should not heap opprobrium on a Siamese cat for not being as boofy as a Burmese cat. Due to its (no apostrophe please) irrevocable lack of Burmeseness.

8:50 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home